National News

Hospital Fires Nurses While Others Resign Over Mandatory Flu Shot

View Comments (3)Print ArticleEmail Article

An Indiana hospital has fired eight employees, including a number of veteran nurses, for refusing to receive a flu shot. 

In early September, Goshen reportedly informed its staff that flu shots would no longer be optional. Beginning this year, all of the hospital's staff, affiliated physicians, volunteers and vendors are required to receive a flu vaccination or apply for an exemption.

At least four of the nurses who were terminated tried to appeal the vaccine on religious grounds with the help of a lawyer, according to several published reports, but a hospital spokesperson said the eight workers who were fired did not fall under guidelines that would have granted them exemptions.

"Some of these individuals had very strongly held personal beliefs, but those are not considered religious beliefs," hospital spokesperson Melanie McDonald told NBC affiliate WNDU in South Bend, IN. "Medical exemptions, the ones that are accepted, are severe allergies that are often life-threatening."

McDonald said the implications of the policy were made clear from the day it was announced, and that the policy covers everyone who has contact with patient. The concern, she said, was that the flu could be deadly to some patients with compromised immune systems.

Three of the former nurses, Sue Schrock, a hospice nurse, Ethel Hoover, a critical care nurse, and Joyce Gingerich, who worked as an oncology nurse at the facility off and on since 1987, told the Elkhart Truth they were not surprised at their firings.

Hoover told the newspaper she had wrestled with the idea of receiving a flu shot before ultimately refused the vaccination and fiiling her exemption request, her request denied, she was terminated from her job a month short of her 22nd anniversary at the hospital.

The last time Hoover had a flu shot was about 20 years ago, she reportedly said, but when she got sick following the shot once she decided to never take one again, adding that she was also worried about long-term health effects from the vaccination.

"Your body has its natural responses to fight off certain viruses and infections, and if you continually inoculate your body with something that's not even guaranteed from preventing you from getting it, why would you do it," Hoover asked rhetorically during the interview.

"I was prepared to stand up for my rights and go for it," Schrock, who had worked for the hospital as a hospice nurse on and off for the past 40 years, told the newspaper in Elkhart, IN.

Schrock said she will continue working as an on-call nurse at a doctor's office in Goshen while she hunts for another job. But this experience has changed her outlook on the Goshen hopsital.

"I don't care if I ever walk through those doors again, but I'm going to miss it," she said. "I love my hospice patients, and I love my hospice colleagues. I will miss them immensely." In an interview with WSBT-TV, Schrock said her decsion to refuse the flu shot and accept the consquences was very much God-led. 

Hoover told the Elkhart Truth she does not plan to go back into nursing unless it is for private care. Like Schrock and Gingerich, she will miss her job at the hospital. "I have enjoyed my patients, and my patients have thoroughly enjoyed me," she said.

Gingerich reportedly said leaving her job was one of the toughest decisions she's ever had to make.

"I worked with a phenomenal group of people in the oncology unit, and I miss them terribly," she said. "They are also very sad. Colleagues overall at the hospital were horrified that this was happening, and I'm going to miss them."


National News Archives
  Last Post: January 8, 2013 | View Comments(3)

It's interesting that HCWs are required to be vaccinated but not doctors or visitors or pts.
It's wrong to take away their right to choose. There is no data to show that unvaccinated workers have caused harm. There's no proof that the vaccine works. It's all about big pharma money. Hospitals have bigger infection problems such as environments that spread resistant organisms. Hospitals need to commit resources to protect pts fron infection instead of pursuing some ridiculous money driven vaccine policy....Quit picking on a few courageous people who are smart enough not to risk their health...these are people who are advocates for patients.

Hana Jamel,  RnJanuary 08, 2013
CA



My heart goes out the the nurses who lost their jobs d/t refusal of the flu shot. I totally understand their position. Getting the shot does not mean you can't get the flu. Having a healthy immune system is one of your best preventatives. Yearly flu shots can compromise your immune system. Birth to death flu shots are a bad idea. I am a nurse, don't get the flu shot and wear a mask required by my facility during the 6month flu season.

karen christopherJanuary 04, 2013
spring hill, TN



The flu vaccine is just a recommendation. The medical professionals need to stand up for the rights of the individual not the medical facility. The hospitals can not control the physician, visitors, and vendors to all have a flue shot or any other shot. The should be worrying about MRSA instead of firing someone that refused a flu vaccine. Please people unite and take a stand for these nurse and hospital personnel.

Kathy CrosasJanuary 04, 2013
Collierville, TN




     

Email: *

Email, first name, comment and security code are required fields; all other fields are optional. With the exception of email, any information you provide will be displayed with your comment.

First * Last
Name:
Title Field Facility
Work:
City State
Location:

Comments: *
To prevent comment spam, please type the code you see below into the code field before submitting your comment. If you cannot read the numbers in the below image, reload the page to generate a new one.

Captcha
Enter the security code below: *

Fields marked with an * are required.

 
http://nursing.advanceweb.com/Web-Extras/Online-Articles/2014-New-Grad-Digital-Edition.aspx
http://shop.advanceweb.com/clearance.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/search/jobview/392603/rn-opportunities.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/healthcare/featuredemployerdetails.html?id=800&jobb&jobb=#forward
http://www.beaschoolnurse.com
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/healthcare/featuredemployerdetails.html?id=1015&jobb=#forward
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/search/jobview/394680/rn--registered-clinical-nurse-ii-medical-surgical-3-east.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/healthcare/featuredemployerdetails.html?id=1468
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/search/employer/3094/hca-west-florida-division.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/search/employer/1505/holy-cross-hospital.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/healthcare/index.html
http://www.advanceweb.com/jobs/search/jobview/394630/registered-nurse-rn--er.html